Carboxylic Acids and Derivatives
0. What Examiners Want
- Reagents and conditions: acidified K2Cr2O7 or KMnO4 under reflux; dilute HCl or H2SO4 or NaOH(aq) under reflux for hydrolysis; concentrated H2SO4 and reflux for esterification; LiAlH4 in dry ether.
- Equations: salt formation with a metal, an alkali and a carbonate; nitrile and ester hydrolysis; esterification (with an equilibrium sign); reduction with [H]. All must balance.
- Naming: carboxylic acids (-oic acid), carboxylate salts (-oate) and esters (alkyl -oate, in the right order).
- Calculations: moles of acid from a mass, moles of gas from a volume at room conditions (24.0 dm3) or s.t.p. (22.4 dm3), and an Mr or percentage composition to identify an acid or an ester. Use the Periodic Table and the gas volumes in the Data Booklet.
- Deduction and linking: choose a route of two or three steps using Topics 15 to 18, and identify an ester from its hydrolysis products.
Where this topic appears. Recent AS papers have asked for: the products when LiAlH4 reduces an acid (and the fact that it does not reduce a C=C bond); the pair of hydrolysis products of an ester that contains a given percentage of oxygen; the sodium salt formed when ethyl butanoate is hydrolysed by dilute NaOH; the Mr of an acid from the mass reacting with magnesium and the volume of H2 at s.t.p.; a sequence in which propanoic acid is reduced and the product is dehydrated; the table comparing hydrolysis of an ester with alkali and with acid; propanoic acid made from chloroethane through a nitrile, the equation of the acid with calcium and its conditions when made from propan-1-ol; and a route from a halogenoalkane through KCN, nitrile hydrolysis and esterification. Infrared absorptions of O–H and C=O in acids and esters are met in Topic 22.
1. Structure, Naming and Weak-Acid Behaviour
A carboxylic acid contains the carboxyl group, –COOH: a C=O and an O–H on the same carbon atom. The carbon is sp2 hybridised and planar. The acid is named from the alkane with -oic acid, and the COOH carbon is always C1, so no number is needed for it.
| Acid | Formula | Salt (with sodium) |
|---|---|---|
| methanoic acid | HCOOH | sodium methanoate |
| ethanoic acid | CH3COOH | sodium ethanoate |
| propanoic acid | CH3CH2COOH | sodium propanoate |
| butanoic acid | CH3CH2CH2COOH | sodium butanoate |
Properties. The O–H group and the C=O group let acid molecules form hydrogen bonds with one another and with water. As a result carboxylic acids have higher boiling points than alcohols or aldehydes of similar Mr, and the smaller ones mix with water.
Weak acids. In water a small proportion of the molecules ionise to give H+:
CH3COOH(aq) ⇌ CH3COO−(aq) + H+(aq)
The equilibrium lies far to the left (Ka for ethanoic acid is 1.7 × 10−5 mol dm−3), so the solution has a pH below 7 but higher than that of a strong acid of the same concentration, and contains mainly un-ionised molecules. A strong acid such as HCl ionises completely. This explains why ethanoic acid reacts more slowly with magnesium than hydrochloric acid of the same concentration: its H+ concentration is lower, but the reaction still goes to completion as the equilibrium shifts.
2. Making Carboxylic Acids
Oxidation of a primary alcohol or an aldehyde. Heat under reflux with excess acidified potassium dichromate(VI) (or acidified potassium manganate(VII)). The orange dichromate ions are reduced to green Cr3+. Using [O] for the oxidising agent:
- CH3CH2OH + 2[O] → CH3COOH + H2O (the alcohol is oxidised through the aldehyde to the acid)
- CH3CHO + [O] → CH3COOH
Reflux keeps the volatile aldehyde in the flask so that it is oxidised right through. Distilling it off as it forms (Topic 17) would stop the oxidation at the aldehyde. A secondary alcohol gives a ketone, not an acid, and a tertiary alcohol is not oxidised.
Hydrolysis of a nitrile. The nitrile carbon becomes the carboxyl carbon, so the chain length is unchanged: propanenitrile, CH3CH2CN, gives propanoic acid.
- With dilute acid and reflux the acid forms directly: CH3CH2CN + 2H2O + HCl → CH3CH2COOH + NH4Cl
- With dilute NaOH(aq) and reflux the sodium salt forms (and ammonia is given off): CH3CH2CN + NaOH + H2O → CH3CH2COONa + NH3. Add dilute acid to the cooled mixture to release CH3CH2COOH.
Hydrolysis of an ester. Reflux with dilute acid gives the carboxylic acid and the alcohol; reflux with dilute NaOH gives the salt, and acidifying releases the acid (Section 6).
Making a nitrile. A halogenoalkane is heated under reflux with KCN in ethanol (Topic 15): CH3CH2Br + KCN → CH3CH2CN + KBr. The sequence halogenoalkane → nitrile → carboxylic acid adds one carbon atom to the chain. (The other route to a nitrile, from an aldehyde or ketone with HCN, is in Topic 17.)
3. Reactions of Carboxylic Acids as Acids
Because they release H+, carboxylic acids show the typical reactions of an acid. Each gives a carboxylate salt:
- Reactive metal: 2CH3COOH + Mg → (CH3COO)2Mg + H2. Bubbles of hydrogen; the metal dissolves. With calcium, propanoic acid gives calcium propanoate: 2CH3CH2COOH + Ca → (CH3CH2COO)2Ca + H2.
- Alkali: CH3COOH + NaOH → CH3COONa + H2O.
- Carbonate: 2CH3COOH + Na2CO3 → 2CH3COONa + H2O + CO2. Effervescence; the gas turns limewater milky. This is the simple test-tube test for a carboxylic acid, because alcohols and esters do not react.
Worked example (using the Data Booklet). A 0.600 g sample of ethanoic acid reacts with excess magnesium. What volume of hydrogen is produced at s.t.p.?
- Mr of CH3COOH = 2 × 12.0 + 4 × 1.0 + 2 × 16.0 = 60.0 (Ar values from the Periodic Table in the Data Booklet).
- Amount of acid = 0.600 / 60.0 = 0.0100 mol.
- From the equation 2 mol of acid give 1 mol of H2, so amount of H2 = 0.00500 mol.
- At s.t.p. one mole of gas occupies 22.4 dm3 (Data Booklet), so volume = 0.00500 × 22.4 = 0.112 dm3 = 112 cm3. At room temperature and pressure the molar volume is 24.0 dm3, which would give 120 cm3.
Working backwards. If a known mass of a monoprotic acid gives a measured volume of gas, find the amount of gas, double it (for hydrogen) to get the amount of acid, then divide the mass by that amount to get Mr. Check whether the acid is monoprotic (one COOH) or dibasic (two COOH): a dibasic acid gives twice as much hydrogen per mole.
4. Reduction to Primary Alcohols
A carboxylic acid is reduced to a primary alcohol by LiAlH4 in dry ether at room temperature. LiAlH4 reacts violently with water, so the ether must be dry.
CH3COOH + 4[H] → CH3CH2OH + H2O
CH3CH2COOH + 4[H] → CH3CH2CH2OH + H2O
Compare the aldehyde, which needs only 2[H] (Topic 17). NaBH4 is too weak to reduce a carboxylic acid, so aqueous NaBH4 leaves it unchanged. LiAlH4 reduces the C=O of the acid but does not reduce a C=C bond, so an alkene is left unchanged.
A typical sequence. Propanoic acid → (LiAlH4, dry ether) propan-1-ol → (concentrated H2SO4, heat; or passing the vapour over hot H3PO4) propene. The second step is the dehydration (elimination) of an alcohol from Topic 16.
5. Esters and Esterification
An ester contains the group –COO– between two carbon chains, RCOOR′. It is made by heating a carboxylic acid with an alcohol under reflux with a few drops of concentrated sulfuric acid as catalyst:
CH3COOH + CH3CH2OH ⇌ CH3COOCH2CH3 + H2O
This is a condensation reaction (a small molecule, water, is lost when two molecules join) and it is reversible, so the product is an equilibrium mixture of acid, alcohol, ester and water. The yield is raised by using an excess of one reactant (usually the cheaper one) or by distilling off the ester as it forms. Esters have sweet, fruity smells and are used as flavourings, perfumes and solvents. They have lower boiling points than carboxylic acids of similar Mr because they have no O–H group and so cannot form hydrogen bonds with each other.
Naming an ester. The first word comes from the alcohol (alkyl) and the second word comes from the acid (-oate).
| Acid | Alcohol | Ester |
|---|---|---|
| ethanoic acid | ethanol | ethyl ethanoate, CH3COOCH2CH3 |
| propanoic acid | ethanol | ethyl propanoate, CH3CH2COOCH2CH3 |
| propanoic acid | methanol | methyl propanoate, CH3CH2COOCH3 |
| ethanoic acid | butan-1-ol | butyl ethanoate, CH3COOCH2CH2CH2CH3 |
When you write the formula, write the acid part first: CH3CH2COOCH3 is methyl propanoate (the acid has three carbons, the alcohol has one), whereas CH3COOCH2CH3 is ethyl ethanoate.
6. Hydrolysis of Esters
Hydrolysis splits an ester back into its acid part and alcohol part. Both methods use heat under reflux.
| Dilute acid (H2SO4 or HCl) | Dilute alkali (NaOH(aq)) | |
|---|---|---|
| Equation (ethyl ethanoate) | CH3COOCH2CH3 + H2O ⇌ CH3COOH + CH3CH2OH | CH3COOCH2CH3 + NaOH → CH3COONa + CH3CH2OH |
| Extent | reversible: an equilibrium mixture | goes to completion |
| Organic products | carboxylic acid and alcohol | sodium carboxylate (salt) and alcohol |
Why the difference? Acid hydrolysis is simply esterification run in reverse, so it reaches an equilibrium and some ester always remains. In alkali the acid is removed as its carboxylate ion, CH3COO−, which does not react with the alcohol, so the reaction cannot go backwards and all the ester can be hydrolysed (if there is enough alkali). To obtain the free acid after alkali hydrolysis, add dilute HCl or H2SO4: CH3COONa + HCl → CH3COOH + NaCl.
Worked example. Ethyl butanoate is heated under reflux with excess dilute NaOH(aq). CH3CH2CH2COOCH2CH3 + NaOH → CH3CH2CH2COONa + CH3CH2OH. The organic products are sodium butanoate and ethanol. The sodium salt comes from the acid part of the name (butanoate) and the alcohol from the first word (ethyl).
Worked example (identifying an ester). Compound X contains a single ester group and 27.6% oxygen by mass. Which pair of products could come from its hydrolysis: butan-1-ol and ethanoic acid, ethanol and propanoic acid, methanol and methanoic acid, or propan-2-ol and butanoic acid? One ester group contains two oxygen atoms (2 × 16.0 = 32.0), so Mr = 32.0 / 0.276 = 116 (Ar values from the Data Booklet). The formula is C6H12O2 (6 × 12.0 + 12 × 1.0 + 2 × 16.0 = 116). The acid and alcohol must together supply six carbon atoms in the ester, and the pair that adds up to six carbons is butan-1-ol (4) and ethanoic acid (2). Ethanol and propanoic acid give five carbons, and propan-2-ol with butanoic acid gives seven.
7. Distinguishing Compounds and Linking Routes
| Compound | Na2CO3(aq) | Acidified K2Cr2O7, warm | 2,4-DNPH |
|---|---|---|---|
| carboxylic acid | fizzes (CO2) | stays orange | no ppt |
| primary alcohol | no reaction | orange to green | no ppt |
| ester | no reaction | stays orange | no ppt |
| aldehyde | no reaction | orange to green | orange ppt |
An ester can be recognised by its fruity smell, and by hydrolysis with hot NaOH(aq) followed by identification of the products: the acid from the salt by adding acid and testing with Na2CO3, and the alcohol by distillation and the dichromate or iodine tests.
Linking reactions into routes. For example, bromoethane to methyl propanoate:
| Step | Reagents and conditions | Product |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | KCN in ethanol, heat under reflux | propanenitrile |
| 2 | dilute HCl (or H2SO4), heat under reflux | propanoic acid |
| 3 | methanol, a few drops of concentrated H2SO4, heat under reflux | methyl propanoate |
And ethanol to ethyl ethanoate: oxidise with excess acidified K2Cr2O7 under reflux to ethanoic acid, then heat the acid with more ethanol and concentrated H2SO4. Always give the reagent, the conditions and the intermediate for each step (Topic 21 builds on this).
Worked deduction. An ester W (Mr = 102.0) is hydrolysed by hot dilute NaOH to give a salt of a two-carbon acid and an alcohol X, which gives a yellow precipitate with alkaline aqueous iodine. The ester has formula C5H10O2 (5 × 12.0 + 10 × 1.0 + 2 × 16.0 = 102.0). The acid is ethanoic acid (2 carbons), so X has 3 carbons. X gives the iodine test, so it contains CH3CH(OH)–: X is propan-2-ol and W is propan-2-yl ethanoate, CH3COOCH(CH3)2.
8. Quick Sheet and Checklist
| Topic | Key point |
|---|---|
| Naming | alkane − e + -oic acid; salt -oate; ester alkyl (alcohol) + -oate (acid) |
| Weak acid | partial ionisation, ⇌; Ka(ethanoic acid) = 1.7 × 10−5 mol dm−3 |
| Making | 1° alcohol or aldehyde, excess K2Cr2O7/H+, reflux; nitrile + dilute acid, reflux; ester hydrolysis |
| With metal | salt + H2 (2 mol RCOOH per mol H2) |
| With alkali | salt + H2O |
| With carbonate | salt + H2O + CO2 (fizz, limewater milky) |
| Reduction | LiAlH4, dry ether: RCOOH + 4[H] → RCH2OH + H2O; NaBH4 does not work |
| Esterification | acid + alcohol, conc. H2SO4, reflux; reversible; ester + water |
| Acid hydrolysis | dilute acid, reflux; reversible; acid + alcohol |
| Alkali hydrolysis | dilute NaOH, reflux; complete; salt + alcohol; acidify to get the acid |
| Gas volumes | 24.0 dm3 mol−1 at room conditions; 22.4 dm3 mol−1 at s.t.p. (Data Booklet) |
Before you leave the question, check:
- Oxidation to the acid says reflux and excess acidified potassium dichromate(VI) (or KMnO4).
- Nitrile hydrolysis keeps the same carbon count; alkali gives the salt, so acidify to get the acid.
- Equations for metals, alkalis and carbonates give the salt by name (-oate) and balance (2 mol acid for 1 mol H2 or CO2).
- Reduction names LiAlH4 in dry ether and uses 4[H]; NaBH4 is not accepted.
- Esterification: concentrated H2SO4, reflux, ⇌ sign, water as the second product; the ester name starts with the alcohol part.
- Hydrolysis: acid is reversible (⇌, acid and alcohol); alkali is complete (→, salt and alcohol).
- Gas calculations use 22.4 (s.t.p.) or 24.0 (room conditions) from the Data Booklet, with cm3 converted to dm3.